@amit I am not sure, or don't remmeber the reason why On This Day does not work with newer themes, maybe @manton can explain it better.
Replying to:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/151d4/151d4e84842f81c83322bb71612a5d86b357afc4" alt="amit"
@amit I am not sure, or don't remmeber the reason why On This Day does not work with newer themes, maybe @manton can explain it better.